Verse 6 has always been one of those, "huh?" moments for me. Read it again and consider how this seemingly random colloquialism fits into the judgement teaching before it, and the ask/seek/knock teaching afterward.
Now, you may be really smart and right now you're thinking "duh, it makes perfect sense." Well, feel free to enlighten me, but like I said, I've always wrestled with this text.
The "traditional" way to interpret this verse is that Jesus is telling us to be careful who we share the Gospel with. Don't just go out there sharing it willy-nilly, some people don't know what a treasure it is and they'll turn on you and tear you to pieces. Be wise in who you evangelize.
This does not sit well with me. Maybe that's my problem. But it just doesn't seem like we should be going around judging people on a scale of "will listen" to "won't listen" based on our human assumptions (which we base mostly on appearance, and we know that's not good because John 7:24). Also, the context here does not touch on evangelism in any way; plus, it doesn't seem like the listeners would have made that connection at all, since Jesus is talking to a large crowd, which includes his disciples, but also contains what you might call the "general public."
So how does this fit? What does it mean? Someone quoted this scripture at me once when I was making mocking a song they liked. I don't think that's why it's there.
Well, I'm preparing to address the "don't judge" teaching at a class at a youth rally next weekend so I wanted to make sure I had a good grasp of the passage. I've done a lot of reading. One thing I came across was the suggestion that verses 1-12 are not 3 random teachings strung together, but one teaching based around the "golden rule."
It makes sense, because verse 12, the golden rule, is the broader application of the "don't judge or you will be judged,"concept. Bookends if you will.
This author still didn't treat verse 6 to my satisfaction, however. How does throwing pearls before swine bridge the parallels? And what is the "it" when Jesus says, "Ask and it will be given to you,"?
This is what I came up with, and I am totally open to criticism and second-guessing:
This section is in a ABCBA format. An idea is introduced, supported, elaborated, supported again in a similar but different way, then repeated. Thusly:
A. Don't judge your brother, or you will be judged in the same way.So, my assertion is that "what is sacred" and the "pearls" represent our brothers and sisters in Christ. We are, after all, called to be a holy people, set aside for God, and by judging God's children harshly we are treating something which God has made holy as unclean, dirty, without value.
B. Discern and remove the sin from your own life before you seek to remove the sins of others.
C. Don't toss your brother aside in judgement, thereby treating him as anything other than the holy child of God he is.
B1. If you need godly wisdom and discernment in these things, just ask. It will be given to you.
A1. Treat others the way you want to be treated.
This is the only way I can make sense of this section. The only other alternative is to treat each small teaching as examples of "sayings of Jesus," of which Matthew is simply listing, and Jesus may or may not have actually said these things in this order, back to back, in one sermon. In that case, the dog/pearl analogy is lost on me, but I still don't think it is telling us not so share the gospel with people we deem unworthy. But I could be wrong.
What do you think? I'm eager to hear other people's thoughts on this.




